|
The
trucking industry needs a consistent, reliable, and up-to-date industry
standard, or benchmark, for the amount of revenue a trucking company can
reasonably expect from a load in a DPM (dollar per mile) format.
The problem is that there is nowhere to get this information in
real-time. “For cars there are
many third party services that estimate operating costs… as a service to
potential buyers. No similar
service exists for trucks” (12). Many
studies and reports have been comprised over the years calculating the current
costs of the day, but the problem with these reports is that they are out-dated
before they are even printed.
“Managers
need to have enough information about their costs to make the right decision
about the type of services to provide and the prices to charge” (1).
While this statement holds truth, we would add that accurate and timely
information is equally as important.
Levinson, Corbett and Hashami (2) who wrote “Operating Costs for Trucks” state
that “fuel, repair and maintenance, tire, depreciation, and labor cost are the
most important costs that are considered in the estimation of operating cost
per kilometer.” How many of these
costs fluctuate over time? How
many of these costs can fluctuate in a matter of weeks or even days?
FairTran® gathers real-time data
to incorporate it into industry-accepted methods and calculations in order to
broadcast it to customers so that they can make accurate, timely, and informed
decisions. This is a “Patent
Pending” business model on file with the United States Patent and Trademark
Office.
Mark
Berwick (3), author of “Truck
Costs for Owner/Operators” claims that “Owner Operators and users of Owner
Operators need truck cost information to benchmark performance against
competitors and industry standards.”
The difficulty is in comparing your business against industry benchmarks –
especially when the data you are looking at is a couple weeks to a couple
months old. He also states that
“basic to any business is the understanding and command of its costs.” (3)
How can we command our costs without comparing costs?
When a business compares costs, they normally compare against the same
time period from the year before. However,
in the trucking industry, we need comparisons in real-time, not from the
previous year.
FairTran®
incorporates the research and data from a wide variety of sources in order to
come up with the most accurate and industry-wide acceptable method to calculate
costs and profits. After
conducting a literature review to evaluate past studies, data, and methods, we
formed a more contemporary costing method.
We use percentages and calculation methods on certain expenses gathered from
this literature including: tires, licenses, profit margins, ROI, depreciation,
communications, etc. However, we
combine these percentages and methods with real-time data from the Consumer
Price Index, US Stock Exchange, Producer Price Index, real-time fuel prices
from over 800 reporting fueling stations, NADA, and more in order to combine
time-tested research with updated information.
Types
of Costs
Driver:
After our research, we chose a national company specializing in
salary information to provide our system with truck driver salary information.
This company’s information fell in line with the literature reviewed.
Depreciation:
We use the straight line depreciation method to divide the
difference between the purchase cost and the salvage cost divided by the
average of the life span of the tractor (5 years) and the average life span of
the trailer (8 years). Because of
the mechanical nature of refrigerated trailers, we chose to give them the same
life span as that of the tractor (5 years).
This falls in line with the literatures cost percentages.
Fuel:
Fuel costs can vary greatly over a short amount of time which is
one of the problems with set percentages for fuel and older reports.
For this reason, we calculate the National FairTran®
Value off of the US Department of Energy’s National Average each week.
For our subscribers, we calculate daily averages from reporting fueling
stations across the country. We
derive our daily Fuel Surcharge from these daily averages and the weekly Fuel
Surcharge is derived from the national DOE weekly average.
The Fuel Surcharge percentage is the percentage correlating to the
appropriate current diesel price on our FairTran®
Fuel Surcharge Schedule.
Administration:
Administrative costs include buildings, electronic
equipment, employees, paper, copy machines, etc.
This area of costing is difficult to determine because of the wide range
of size differences between companies.
We considered the economies of scale (or scope), which is where “larger firms
would reduce cost so that larger companies would have a lower cost per
distance” (2). This formula is
C(y1, y2)<C(o,y2)+C(y1,0). However,
research and literature indicates that there is minimal impact on the economies
of scale in transportation (6). Berwick
puts it like this, “The large number of small firms operating in the motor
carrier industry should attest that economies of size are not extensive” (3).
Economies of utilization, on the other hand, provide huge paybacks.
Economies of utilization suggest that the more you drive your truck the
less your fixed costs become per mile.
“Fixed costs are short-run costs that cannot be avoided and do not vary with
output” (7).
ROI:
We calculate the Return On Investment as outlined in the literature.
The interest rate is updated according to a widely known national bank
rate.
Maintenance
and Repair: Includes
the maintenance and repair of the truck and trailer without consideration for
tires (a separate cost since they vary in price over time).
We use our research and literature to derive the maintenance cost
percentages and is after the weight adjustment in the method from Berwick (3)
which adds and adjustment of .00097 per 1,000 lbs over 58,000 lbs.
We assume a percentage empty for vans, flatbeds, and tankers varying by
trailer type.
Tires:
Berwick states that weight above 3,500 pounds per tire increases a .7 in wear
for each 1% increase in weight. We
assume from the literature that tractor tires have a 204,500 mile life and
trailers tires have a 100,000 mile life.
We obtain tire pricing from a national company and average two steer and 8
drive tires for a per tire cost for tractors.
We also assume that the combo is running a GVW of 80,000 pounds.
We adjust the tire pricing each month.
Therefore, Custom FairTran® Values will
allow you to gain miles per gallon and reduced maintenance and repair for
transportation companies hauling less weight on average.
Insurance:
We are using the percentage estimate from the literature for all
trailers except reefers. We
are using a higher percentage insurance costs for reefers based on their higher
risk of product damage due to refrigeration failure, untimely deliveries, etc.
Licenses/Misc:
Based on research, we are taking the average of the literature cost
percentages.
Margin:
Instead of narrowing it down to one percentage when the
market changes constantly, we have decided to use a profit margin formula and
major publicly traded trucking companies as an index for our range.
Miles
Per Gallon: MPG
has a wide range depending on what and where a trucking company is hauling and
with what equipment. Research
indicates that mpg is from 5-7 mpg.
We are going to use 6 mpg but it will be adjusted using Knapton’s fuel
efficiency formula combined with Ryder’s theory that for every 1 mph gain in
speed over 55 mph, fuel economy drops 2%.
We use the average speed of 55 mph and a GVW of 80,000.
Custom FairTran® customers have
the option to take advantage of this calculation by plugging in their own GVW
and speed to calculate a more accurate mpg for their company.
They can also just plug in a flat mpg from which to calculate.
Communications:
Communications include phone, cell phone, internet, etc.
We are accepting the cost percentage that the literature suggests.
Assumptions
Yearly
Mileage: Research and
literature review shows a typical truck to run 100,000 (10).
Other research states that most owner operators are trying to operate at
or above 100,000 a year or between 100,000-150,000 miles.
FairTran® assumes 115,000 miles
per year for long haul and 65,000 miles per year for short haul adjusted
proportionately by the average speed setting.
Average
Speed: 55 mph (11)
Tractor
Life: 5 years (9)
Trailer
Life: 5 years for a reefer and 8 years (9) for the others
Transformation
of Information:
FairTran®
transforms information into a valuable commodity by using our calculation
method and broadcasting process to instantly assess the market place and update
our customers on the go like never before .
This “Patent Pending” method is a valuable service to our subscribers.
References:
1.
“Learning about Transport Costs,”Braeutigam.
2.
“Operating Costs for Trucks”, David Levinson (Corresponding Author),
Michael Corbett, Maryam Hashami. Department of Civil Engineering, University of
Minnesota
3.
“Truck Costs for Owner/Operators”, Mark Berwick, Upper Great Plans
Transportation Institute, North Dakota State University
4.
“2009 Edition Partners in Business, A Business Manual for
Owner-Operators”, Michelle Moeck
(Overdrive), ATBS consultants.
5.
“Basic Theory of Calculating Costs: Applications to Trucking”, Upper
Great Plains Transportation Institute, North Dakota State University.
6.
“Transportation”, Coyle, Bardi, Novack. West Publishing Company.
7.
“Managerial Economics 7th ed.”, Hirschey, Pappas, The Dryden
Press.
8.
“Comprehensive Truck Size and Weight (TS&W) Study Phase 1-Synthesis,
Truck Costs and Truck Size and Weight Regulations”, Working Paper 7, Battelle
Team.
9.
“Operating Costs of Trucks in Canada 2005”, Logistics Solution Builders,
Inc.
10.
“Operating Costs and Characteristics of North Dakota Grain Trucking
Firms,” Dooley, Upper Great Plains Transportation Institute, North Dakota State
University.
11.
“Fuel-Efficient Driving: The Basics”, Ryder, Heavy Duty Trucking 73.
12. “The Per-Mile Costs of Operating Automobiles and Trucks”, Barnes,
Langworthy, Humphrey
Institute of Public Affairs, University of Minnesota.
|